Memorial Day weekend in 1981 I proposed to Donna, in Virginia’s beautiful Shenandoah National Park (she said yes). We stayed at the rustic Skyland Lodge, between mile markers 41 and 42 on the scenic 105-mile-long Skyline Drive that runs along the crest of the Blue Ridge Mountains through the park. Recently we decided to return to that romantic spot and a momentous time in our lives. Donna booked a room at the still-standing Skyland Lodge and we began our online search for the place where we started our together lives. The spot where I knelt those 45 years ago was by the base of a tall waterfall. We couldn’t recall its location or name but thought that with a little digging we could find it. There are dozens of trails in the park with varying lengths and levels of difficulty, and more than a dozen named waterfalls, and many more smaller, unnamed falls. Back then we were not hikers; we didn’t own hiking shoes or backpacks, so it couldn’t have been too far off a parking lot or pul...