Skip to main content

Oh Shenandoah – The Great Waterfall Mystery

Memorial Day weekend in 1981 I proposed to Donna, in Virginia’s beautiful Shenandoah National Park (she said yes). We stayed at the rustic Skyland Lodge, between mile markers 41 and 42 on the scenic 105-mile-long Skyline Drive that runs along the crest of the Blue Ridge Mountains through the park.

Recently we decided to return to that romantic spot and a momentous time in our lives. Donna booked a room at the still-standing Skyland Lodge and we began our online search for the place where we started our together lives.

The spot where I knelt those 45 years ago was by the base of a tall waterfall. We couldn’t recall its location or name but thought that with a little digging we could find it.

There are dozens of trails in the park with varying lengths and levels of difficulty, and more than a dozen named waterfalls, and many more smaller, unnamed falls.

Back then we were not hikers; we didn’t own hiking shoes or backpacks, so it couldn’t have been too far off a parking lot or pull-off (although we were 45 years younger and maybe what seems strenuous today was an easy stroll back then). We both have memories of being behind the falls.

We delved into online resources about waterfalls in the park, first of those near Skyland, then, failing to identify plausible sites, we widened our search to any falls in the park not requiring more than a mile of strenuous hiking.  We came up empty handed – of the larger waterfalls in the park, few are easily accessible. No matter, we thought; when we get to the lodge, we’ll ask for help. Surely they will know of a close-by falls.

The drive to the park is gorgeous, dotted with quaint towns and beautiful scenery. Once on Skyland Drive, however, the views of the Blue Ridge Mountains, and behind them, the Appalachian Mountains, are breathtaking. There are many scenic overlooks that provide vistas that are hard to describe: millions of trees covering seemingly endless hills and valleys, and beyond that the majestic blue ridgelines of ageless mountains. The vastness of it is similar to seeing the Grand Canyon from its rim: There is an odd beauty in feeling so insignificant among such bigness.

We arrived at the lodge around 1 pm already dressed for hiking. Our room wasn’t ready but the woman at the front desk suggested a couple trails for an afternoon hike: one whose trailhead was very close to the lodge was a 3-mile, moderately strenuous loop along the Little Stony Man Cliffs to the 4,000-foot summit with a wonderful vista; the other trail, a nine-mile drive away, was just 1.4-miles long and terminates at a 70-foot waterfall called Dark Hollow Falls. Perhaps that was our proposal falls?

We opted for the close vista hike and to save the Dark Hollow Falls hike, which we imagined could be our proposal falls, for the next day. We grabbed a quick bite to eat and started off.

The trail was through thick forest, with lots of switchbacks. The summit is a popular destination and when we arrived there were a handful of other hikers admiring the spectacular view from atop boulders. We joined them for about 10 minutes before returning to the lodge. We checked in, got cleaned up, had a good, hearty meal at the lodge’s dining room, then returned to the deck off our room for a magnificent sunset and later, an equally magnificent night sky filled with stars.

The next morning we drove to another lodge, at Big Meadows, to check out the 2.7-mile Lewis Falls Trail. It was a more arduous trek, and like the Stony Man Trail we had hiked the day before, had an elevation gain of close to 1,000 feet. There was not a soul on the trail except for one lone hiker we met at Blackrock Vista.

The trail, more than a mile of which is part of the great Appalachian Trail, takes you deep into the ancient forest where sunlight struggles to penetrate, and the massive rocks and cliffs, fields of ferns, and extreme quiet give you a sense of being in a prehistoric land. We expected to see grazing dinosaurs.

The waterfall, about halfway around the loop, was disappointing. Yes, you could see it and hear it as it cascaded down the mountain, but it didn’t strike you with any sense of awe. For the energy we had exerted in getting to it, including some challenging rock scrabbling – and had to exert to get back to the trailhead – the juice wasn’t worth the squeeze. And it was decidedly not our falls. Still, we enjoyed the beauty and solitude the trail provided, and appreciate that there are such places untouched, as they were millennia ago, available to explore, and experience, and imagine who else or what else may have trod these forests in ages past.

We caught our breath at Big Meadows Lodge, then drove a short distance to the trailhead for Dark Hollow Falls. This, our final hike in Shenandoah, must be it, we reasoned – or more accurately, hoped.

It’s an easy, pleasant hike with a wide trail that follows a stream. One of the most popular trails in Shenandoah, it was bustling with casual hikers. The trail drops hundreds of feet and delivers you to the base of majestic Dark Hollow Falls. The rushing water crashes against the rocks before winding onward as the  Hogcamp Branch of the Rose River. It was beautiful, and stirred within us memories from 45 years ago.

It’s not quite as we remember it, but I think we found our elusive waterfall.

At least, that’s our story, and we’re sticking to it.


































Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Ireland 2019 - Part 1: Random Information, Shepherding Demonstration, Skellig Michael

Donna and I recently joined five of her siblings and their significant others for a trip to Ireland. The two of us went a couple days early to go to Galway with two of Donna’s siblings; we met up with the rest for a week in Dingle. I’ll be writing about this unforgettable vacation in a few installments; in the first I give you some of my random thoughts about Ireland and focus on two activities: a shepherding demonstration and our trip to Skellig Michael. Random information about Ireland  Conciseness is not a common attribute of the loquacious Irish . Nor is the direct conveyance of information. Two examples follow: One day we were searching for children’s clothing in Dingle. At one shop the proprietor said he did not carry what we were looking for, but gave us these directions to a shop that did: “Go to the shop around the corner with the dolphins painted on the side. Not that store, but the one next door. Across the street from that store is a store; the one next...

Great Chesapeake Bay 4.4-Mile Swim

I swam the Great Chesapeake Bay 4.4-Mile Swim last Sunday for the fourth time.  It was the first time I had participated since 2011.  Back then I wasn’t in the best of shape and the conditions were very tough.  The air temperature was 95 and the water temperature above 80.  It was a grueling, unpleasant grind.  I remember telling Donna to never let me do it again. This time it was a completely different experience.  I really enjoyed the swim.  The air and water temperatures were just about perfect (80 degrees and 72 degrees), although seas were pretty rough—especially during the second half of the swim.  I had a better attitude going in, I was physically and mentally prepared, I had a music player—a gift from my kids—to keep my head clear and I was excited for about a week before.  Maybe I needed something to be excited about.   I was excited on the early-morning drive from Columbia, past Annapolis and acr...

Call Me Ishmael

I’ve just finished re-reading Moby Dick , Herman Melville’s American masterpiece about Captain Ahab’s battle with destiny, madness and the great white sperm whale that demasted him of a leg. It’s one of the most remarkable books I’ve ever plowed through. Ishmael, the book’s narrator, signs on to be a shipmate on the whaling ship Pequod for a three-year expedition because he’s drawn to the sea as a way to clear his head and experience the ocean’s vast wildness. As fate would have it though, Ahab, captain of the Pequod , has no intention to harvest as many sperm whales as possible, but to hunt down and kill Moby Dick.   I’m fascinated by literary names. Ahab was named by his “crazy mother” after a biblical king of Israel who devoted himself to the worship of false gods. Like his namesake, Captain Ahab is devoted to the maniacal pursuit of his false god, vengeance. Ishmael in the Bible was the bastard son of Abraham and his wife’s slave Hagar. Abraham’s wife Sarah ban...